As Lionel Messi approaches the end of his inaugural season in Major League Soccer, questions arise about his candidacy for the MVP award. With only 55% of games played, fans and analysts debate whether his influence on the pitch outweighs his limited appearances.
The 2023 MLS season has been defined by one name: Lionel Messi. As the world’s greatest footballer made his high-profile move to Major League Soccer (MLS) with Inter Miami, expectations soared, and so did the anticipation surrounding his MVP candidacy. However, with Messi having played only 55% of his team’s regular-season games, many are now asking: does participation alone warrant MVP honors? More importantly, can Messi’s influence on the pitch, despite his limited appearances, justify his place in the conversation for MLS MVP?
Since joining MLS in the summer of 2023, Lionel Messi’s impact has been immediate and profound. Not only has he elevated the profile of Major League Soccer worldwide, but his on-field performances have transformed Inter Miami into a competitive force. In his short time with the club, Messi has helped lead them to the U.S. Open Cup and Leagues Cup titles, while also contributing heavily to their push for a playoff spot in the MLS regular season.
However, as the season winds down, a critical question emerges: should Messi’s candidacy for MVP be evaluated based on his overall influence and ability to change the game when present, or should more traditional metrics—such as games played and total contributions throughout the season—be given more weight? As analysts, fans, and MLS officials debate this, it’s clear that the debate goes beyond the numbers.
One of the most significant factors in Messi’s MVP case is the number of games he has participated in. As of the end of October 2023, Messi has appeared in just 55% of Inter Miami’s regular season matches. This raises a crucial question: can a player be considered the league’s Most Valuable Player when they’ve been absent for nearly half of their team’s games?
The argument against Messi’s MVP candidacy based on appearances is rooted in the tradition of the award. Historically, the MLS MVP has been awarded to players who have featured consistently over the entire season, showcasing their importance not just in isolated moments but over a broad range of matches. The MVP is meant to recognize a player who can influence their team through sustained performances across an entire campaign.
While Messi’s limited appearances have drawn criticism, his impact during those games is indisputable. In the games Messi has played, his presence has been nothing short of transformative. He has consistently produced moments of magic, scoring crucial goals, providing assists, and fundamentally altering the way Inter Miami play. Messi’s ability to change the course of a match in an instant, whether through a perfectly weighted pass or a brilliant free kick, has proven that even in a limited number of appearances, he can be the most influential player on the pitch.
Moreover, Messi’s off-field influence has been significant. His arrival in Miami has generated an unprecedented global media buzz, boosting the visibility of the league, attracting sponsorships, and bringing a level of attention to MLS that it has never seen before. For many, Messi’s arrival has reshaped the league’s narrative, and this intangible impact cannot be overlooked when considering his candidacy for MVP.
Messi’s MVP bid also comes in the context of strong competition from players who have played more than he has. Several MLS stars have delivered remarkable seasons, and their cases must be evaluated in comparison to Messi’s unique situation.
When comparing these players to Messi, it’s evident that consistency has been their strongest attribute. They’ve delivered at a high level throughout the season, whereas Messi’s impact has been concentrated in a shorter period. This brings us back to the core question: should MVP be awarded solely for consistent performances, or should it also consider a player’s ability to make a disproportionate impact when they are on the field?
Messi’s MVP candidacy raises broader questions about how we evaluate players and value their contributions. While traditional metrics favor longevity and consistency, there is also an argument to be made for recognizing game-changing performances, particularly from global superstars who transcend the usual parameters of performance measurement.
Messi’s situation also forces a reevaluation of the definition of “value” in MVP voting. Should value be solely tied to the number of appearances, or should it also account for a player’s ability to influence their team’s success in high-leverage situations? Messi’s impact on Inter Miami’s success in cup competitions, including their triumph in the Leagues Cup, demonstrates that his value extends beyond just the regular season.
Messi’s presence in MLS has also elevated the league’s profile on the global stage. This influx of international attention has brought new fans, sponsors, and investors to the league, leading to an economic boost for MLS clubs. While this intangible contribution cannot be directly measured in goals or assists, it has played a pivotal role in reshaping how the league is perceived worldwide.
The idea of awarding MVP honors to a player who has had such a profound effect on the league’s visibility and reputation may be controversial, but it is worth considering whether Messi’s off-field contributions could add weight to his MVP candidacy. As the face of MLS’ internationalization, Messi’s role in the league’s growth may go beyond the statistical contributions typically associated with MVP contenders.
The debate surrounding Lionel Messi’s candidacy for the 2023 MLS MVP is not just about his individual performances but about how we evaluate the value of a player’s influence. While his limited appearances might be a factor working against him, his ability to turn games on their head, his leadership on and off the pitch, and his transformative impact on Major League Soccer should not be underestimated. Whether or not Messi wins the MVP, his inaugural season in MLS has already solidified his legacy as one of the most impactful figures in the history of the league.
As the final games of the season approach and the MVP decision looms, one thing is certain: Messi’s presence in MLS has left an indelible mark on the league. Regardless of the outcome of the MVP vote, his influence has been a game-changer for both Inter Miami and the broader MLS community. For more insights on Messi’s MLS journey, visit MLS News.
See more Sky News Portal
Inter Miami owner reveals bold expectations for a potential MLS calendar change.
Concacaf is closely monitoring protests in Los Angeles ahead of the Gold Cup opener.
LAFC secures Javairo Dilrosun on loan from América to enhance their squad.
Sam Coffey's contract with the Portland Thorns has been extended through 2027, solidifying her future…
Paige Bueckers scores 35 points in her return, but Wings suffer a tough loss.
Coney Island's hot dog champion invites Joey Chestnut back, risking his title for the spirit…