Derek Carr’s Retirement: What Lies Ahead for the Saints’ Future?
New Orleans Saints quarterback Derek Carr has announced his retirement after an 11-year NFL career, leaving the franchise at a critical crossroads. The 33-year-old signal-caller, who joined the Saints in 2023 after nine seasons with the Raiders, cited health and family priorities for his decision. With Carr’s departure, New Orleans must now address its quarterback vacancy while navigating salary cap constraints and an evolving NFC South division.
The Immediate Impact on the Saints’ Roster
Carr’s retirement creates a $12 million dead cap hit for the Saints in 2024, compounding existing financial challenges. The team currently sits $28 million over the projected salary cap, according to Spotrac, forcing difficult roster decisions. “Losing a starting quarterback unexpectedly always shakes up a franchise,” said former NFL GM Randy Mueller. “But when it happens amid cap troubles, the domino effect can last years.”
The Saints now face three primary options:
- Promote from within: Backup Jameis Winston has starting experience but completed just 53.2% of passes in limited 2023 action
- Free agency: Potential targets include Ryan Tannehill or Baker Mayfield if Tampa doesn’t re-sign him
- Draft: New Orleans holds the 14th pick but may need to trade up for top QB prospects
Evaluating the Saints’ Long-Term Quarterback Strategy
Head coach Dennis Allen and GM Mickey Loomis now face their most consequential decision since Drew Brees’ retirement. The Saints’ 2023 offensive metrics with Carr (19th in scoring, 21st in red zone efficiency) suggest systemic issues beyond quarterback play. “This isn’t just about replacing Carr’s arm,” noted ESPN analyst Dan Orlovsky. “They need to decide if they’re rebuilding or retooling around aging stars like Alvin Kamara and Cameron Jordan.”
Historical data shows the challenges of sudden QB transitions:
- Teams losing veteran QBs average 2.3 more losses the following season (NFL Research 2010-2023)
- Only 31% of NFC South teams have made playoffs the year after a QB change
- The Saints’ last three QB transitions (2021-2023) resulted in progressively worse win totals (9, 7, 6)
How the NFC South Landscape Factors In
The division remains wide open, with all four teams facing quarterback questions. The Buccaneers must re-sign Mayfield, the Falcons have Desmond Ridder, and the Panthers are developing Bryce Young. This parity could incentivize the Saints to pursue a veteran rather than endure a rebuild.
“The Saints’ window isn’t completely closed,” argued NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport. “With that defense and Michael Thomas returning, a competent game manager might keep them competitive.” However, Pro Football Focus metrics tell a different story—New Orleans’ defense ranked 22nd in EPA/play last season, its worst since 2015.
Potential Contenders for the Saints’ QB Job
Several names have emerged as possible solutions:
Trade Targets: Chicago’s Justin Fields (if drafted over) or Denver’s Russell Wilson could provide short-term stability. Wilson’s $39 million salary makes this unlikely unless Denver eats most of it.
Draft Prospects: At pick 14, the Saints might target Washington’s Michael Penix Jr. or Oregon’s Bo Nix. Both completed over 65% of passes in 2023 with 35+ touchdowns.
Free Agent Options: Ryan Tannehill’s 63.5 career completion percentage and playoff experience could appeal, while Jacoby Brissett posted a 94.1 passer rating in 2022 spot starts.
The Ripple Effects on New Orleans’ Offense
Whoever takes the helm will inherit weapons like Chris Olave (1,042 yards in 2023) and Rashid Shaheed (17.4 yards/catch), but the offensive line allowed pressure on 24.1% of dropbacks (24th in NFL). The Saints must decide whether to:
- Restructure contracts to retain key pieces
- Trade veterans for draft capital
- Overhaul the offensive scheme under coordinator Klint Kubiak
“This offense was built for Carr’s quick-release style,” observed former Saints QB Bobby Hebert. “If they go with a mobile QB or rookie, they’ll need to redesign everything from protection schemes to route trees.”
What History Says About Post-Carr Scenarios
Examining similar transitions reveals patterns. When the Colts lost Andrew Luck in 2019, they cycled through six QBs in four years before drafting Anthony Richardson. Conversely, the Packers seamlessly transitioned from Brett Favre to Aaron Rodgers by planning ahead.
The Saints’ recent draft history shows mixed results:
- Last QB drafted: Ian Book (4th round, 2021) – no longer in NFL
- Last offensive Pro Bowler drafted: Erik McCoy (2019)
- 2023 draft class contributed just 17 starts combined
Looking Ahead: Pivotal Decisions for Saints Leadership
Owner Gayle Benson faces her franchise’s most uncertain offseason since Hurricane Katrina’s aftermath. With the NFL Draft (April 25-27) and free agency (March 13) looming, the Saints’ moves will reveal whether they prioritize:
- Short-term competitiveness in a weak division
- Long-term rebuilding through the draft
- A hybrid approach using bridge quarterbacks
As the Saints navigate this transition, fans can track official updates through the team’s website and training camp reports. One thing remains certain: In a league where quarterback stability dictates success, New Orleans’ path forward will define the franchise for years to come.
See more Sky News Portal
